White Paper – Personal Assistants 5
commissions. In that case, the brokerage would probably charge the personal assistant’s
compensation back to the salesperson at a rate greater than 100 percent in order to cover the
payroll, personnel, and other administrative expenses carried by the brokerage as the personal
assistant’s employer. Finally, from the standpoint of vicarious liability, it may not matter to the
brokerage whether the personal assistant is licensed or unlicensed because the brokerage has the
ability, as the employer, to define the scope of the employee’s duties, to control and supervise the
personal assistant, and thereby to protect itself from being held vicariously liable for conduct by
the personal assistant that is beyond the scope of his or her employment.
Another option would be for the personal assistant to be employed directly by the salesperson for
whom he or she works. Under such an arrangement, the salesperson would handle all of the
payroll and tax reporting details, as well as all of the previously listed employment-related issues
such as interviews, job description, etc., just as the brokerage would in the first scenario. If the
personal assistant were licensed and earned commission income, then issues would arise as to
compliance with state law requirements that such commission-based income be paid by the
brokerage for whom the salesperson works, and not directly by the agent. But if the personal
assistant were unlicensed, then he or she would, or at least should, receive compensation on an
hourly or salary basis, as recommended by the Division of Real Estate. In either case, the most
significant issues involve the salesperson’s potential vicarious liability as an employer and the
extent to which the salesperson’s employment, control, and supervision of the personal assistant
would cut the brokerage off from potential vicarious liability. Although a determination as to
vicarious liability would have to be made on the basis of the individual facts in each case, if the
personal assistant is employed by the salesperson, then, presumably, the salesperson supervises
and controls the personal assistant and defines the scope of his or her employment. In the
generality of cases, such control and supervision by the salesperson as employer should insulate
the brokerage from vicarious liability, unless the brokerage also exerts, as a practical matter,
supervision and control over the personal assistant or unless the brokerage were deemed to
control and supervise the personal assistant by virtue of the brokerage’s relationship with the
salesperson.
Yet a third option is for the personal assistant to be an independent contractor engaged by the
individual salesperson. It should be emphasized, however, that creating this type of relationship
would require the salesperson to refrain from controlling and supervising the day-to-day activities
and details of the personal assistant’s work, and that might prove to be inconsistent with an
effective working relationship between the salesperson and the personal assistant. Nevertheless,
in this scenario, there is an express contractual agreement between the personal assistant and the
salesperson, who typically agrees to pay the personal assistant on the basis of completion of a
specific job in accordance with the terms and conditions of the contract. As was mentioned earlier,
compensating an independent contractor does not require the same payroll withholding and tax
reporting that compensating an employee entails, and it remains true that an unlicensed personal
assistant should not receive commission compensation, regardless of whether he or she is an
employee or an independent contractor. As an independent contractor, the personal assistant
generally will, and probably should, have his or her own office space or facility and furnish his or
her own supplies, materials, and equipment. Otherwise, the line between employee and
independent contractor begins to blur, and payroll and tax withholding problems and vicarious
liability issues begin to arise. As a practical matter, it is uncommon for brokerages to allow their
salespeople to contract independently with personal assistants who are licensed (although some